Opinion
RSS Feed
No shell out
Comment
Ronnie Dungan, Editor, ToyNews
July 10, 2008
Changes may be afoot for next year’s ExCeL Toy Fair.
The talk is of new dates, no weekends and perhaps most importantly of all a shift of emphasis to shell scheme stands.
I don’t think there’s many that wouldn’t welcome a move to a weekday format, affording a little more space in the hectic first quarter trade show schedule and giving a weekend back. Retailers in particular have never been keen on Saturdays, their busiest day of trading.
More controversial, however, is the talk of making the show shell scheme only. It will certainly reduce costs for the small to medium-sized companies but may not make a lot of cost difference to the bigger guys that already own bespoke schemes.
It’s great that there is a real debate about it and that the BTHA is so open-minded. It’s hopefully not too alarmist to say that the show definitely needs something to change.
It is facing the dilemma that all trade shows face at some stage in their life cycle - business or show business? Can a trade event comfortably function as both a business forum and an industry showcase? How can it be all things to all men? Shell scheme will be perfect for some but not represent the brand values that others want to project.
Whichever way it jumps it will not be able to keep everyone happy but at least it will be following the wishes of the majority of its members when any change is made.
The real problem is stand-set up and show dates are all interlinked. You can’t alter one and not affect the other.
Personally, shell scheme is great for certain smaller venues but I think if the show is at ExCeL then it can ill afford to lose its remaining razzmatazz for fear of looking out of place. The industry needs to look confident. I’m not sure shell schemes project that.
My gut feeling is that after some consultation the show will remain as it is. For this year at least.
I don’t think there’s many that wouldn’t welcome a move to a weekday format, affording a little more space in the hectic first quarter trade show schedule and giving a weekend back. Retailers in particular have never been keen on Saturdays, their busiest day of trading.
More controversial, however, is the talk of making the show shell scheme only. It will certainly reduce costs for the small to medium-sized companies but may not make a lot of cost difference to the bigger guys that already own bespoke schemes.
It’s great that there is a real debate about it and that the BTHA is so open-minded. It’s hopefully not too alarmist to say that the show definitely needs something to change.
It is facing the dilemma that all trade shows face at some stage in their life cycle - business or show business? Can a trade event comfortably function as both a business forum and an industry showcase? How can it be all things to all men? Shell scheme will be perfect for some but not represent the brand values that others want to project.
Whichever way it jumps it will not be able to keep everyone happy but at least it will be following the wishes of the majority of its members when any change is made.
The real problem is stand-set up and show dates are all interlinked. You can’t alter one and not affect the other.
Personally, shell scheme is great for certain smaller venues but I think if the show is at ExCeL then it can ill afford to lose its remaining razzmatazz for fear of looking out of place. The industry needs to look confident. I’m not sure shell schemes project that.
My gut feeling is that after some consultation the show will remain as it is. For this year at least.
Recent Columns
- If you can't beat 'em...
August 14 - Comment
- The man from the ministry
July 10 - Counter Insurgent
- You've Got Mail (July)
July 10 - Sarah Holden
- You've Got Mail (June)
June 11 - Nat Southworth
- COMMENT: Safe Pair of Hands
June 3 - Ronnie Dungan
- You've Got Mail (May)
May 27 - Hedley Barnes
- RETAIL SCENE - Construction toy recalls
May 19 - Lutz Muller
- Then there were three
April 29 - Comment
- No sense of humour
April 29 - Counter Insurgent
- Pot. Kettle. Black
April 25 - Counter Insurgent
- Galleon - Going it alone
April 2 - Stephen Green
- COMMENT: Elephants in the room
March 13 - Ronnie Dungan
- The game's not up
February 28 - Comment
- A perfect storm?
February 26 - Simon Birchenough
- Goodbye to all that
December 3 - Comment
- The rail thing
November 21 - Counter Insurgent
- It’s not just toys
November 9 - Licensingpages
- The right platform
October 3 - Licensingpages
- Taboo subjects
October 3 - Simon Gardner
- Feelgood factor
October 3 - Counter Insurgent
- What price loyalty?
October 1 - Comment
- It takes two
August 29 - Ian Downes
- Block bookings
August 29 - Counter Insurgent
- Beware the fakes
August 29 - Licensing Pages
- Olympian dreams
July 28 - Jessica Blue











